Hui Hoang
Ms. Peifer
English 10 IB
26 November 2008
Antigone is proven guilty of the crimes of burial of Polyneices which was forbidden by Creon. Antigone, knowing of the laws and consequences proceeded with burring Polyneices and not denying any of the crimes committed. According to the guard you said that “I admit I did it. I won’t deny that.”(Antigone 500) Why would you commit such a crime of burying the ememy. The laws were very clear “His body must lie in the fields, a sweet tresure for the carrion birds.” (21) We have witness that claims that you were “Spreading thirsty dust onto the flesh and undertaking all appropriate rites.”(264-265)
She had performed a sacred burial for the enemy that was trying to take the throne of Thebes. By law she should be put to death because the king had put out a set of laws that will never be broken. Ismene nearly followed you because of your persuasive talk to help but she being wise and intelligent was not beguiled by your tempting words. You have not only disgraced your siblings but the family and the entire royalty. But sentencing you to death would be to harsh since you were doing this out of your own heart so Antigone should be removed from the land of Thebes and to never return.
Works citedsophocles."Antigone."Sophocles antigone. Trans. Ian Johnston. 9 Aug 2008. Vancouver island university Malaspina. 26 Nov. 2008 <http://records.viu.ca/~johnstoi/Sophocles/Antigone.htm>
Wednesday, November 26, 2008
LRJ 2
Hui Hoang
Ms. Peifer
English 10 IB
26 November 2008
As the two siblings fought in the fields of Thebes for a very long period of time it finally ended in a bloody stalemate. Both were critically injured and they both passed away on the field. In the celebration of their victory and their new king of Thebes, Creon ordered a military funeral for Eteocles as he did not for Polyneices. He warns the people of Thebes not to interfere with the body of Polyneics, “His body must lie in the fields, a sweet tresure for the carrion birds.” (Antigone 21) But Antigone could not let this happen for she still cared for her dear brother Polyneices. Antigone brings Ismene to speak with her in secrecy, she asks for her assistance in the burial of her brother. While Ismene questions her motives Antigone has well decided what she was going to do”Yes. I’ll do my duty to my brother and yours as well.” (59 - 60) Ismene is so afraid of breaking the laws that he left Antigone to go alone.
The next day a guard arrives at the palace to tell Creon of some bad news, “It’s about the corpse. Someone has buried it and disappeared.” (282 - 283) Creon sends the guard to investigate who buried the corpse. Quickly he returns the next day to report of his findings “This here’s the one who carried out the act.We caught her as she was burying the corpse.” (432 -433) The image of this quote brings of importance because no one would ever attempt to break the law made by the king himself but if so how could it be of a women. Creon is quite surprised himself as he realizes what was happening in front of him, anognorisis fill Creons head as he could not belive his own niece would betray him. “You there you with your face bent down towards the ground, what do you say? Do you deny you did this or admit it?” (441 - 443) Creon sentences her to death as he is a man of his word and would not go back on what he has said not to do.
Haimon goes to see Creon about what has happened, Creon assures Haimon that losing Antigone would not affect his life. “Indeed, my son, that’s how your heart should always be resolved, to stand behind your father’s judgment.” (638 – 640) Creon just sees women as objects that can be replaced but Haimon sees it differently. Haimon begins to question Creons actions in defense of Antigone. Haimon leaves angrily threatening his life if Antigone is hurt. Creon did not believe so but a great prophet prophesized many deaths to come. In response Creon went to do the right things but when he arrives at the dungeon Antigone was locked in he finds the Antigone has committed suicide and that his son has done so to. The sudden perpetia overwhelms Creon with emotions as when he returns to the kingdom he finds of the loss of his wife as well leaving him in grief.
Works cited
sophocles."Antigone."Sophocles antigone. Trans. Ian Johnston. 9 Aug 2008. Vancouver island university Malaspina. 26 Nov. 2008 <http://records.viu.ca/~johnstoi/Sophocles/Antigone.htm>
Ms. Peifer
English 10 IB
26 November 2008
As the two siblings fought in the fields of Thebes for a very long period of time it finally ended in a bloody stalemate. Both were critically injured and they both passed away on the field. In the celebration of their victory and their new king of Thebes, Creon ordered a military funeral for Eteocles as he did not for Polyneices. He warns the people of Thebes not to interfere with the body of Polyneics, “His body must lie in the fields, a sweet tresure for the carrion birds.” (Antigone 21) But Antigone could not let this happen for she still cared for her dear brother Polyneices. Antigone brings Ismene to speak with her in secrecy, she asks for her assistance in the burial of her brother. While Ismene questions her motives Antigone has well decided what she was going to do”Yes. I’ll do my duty to my brother and yours as well.” (59 - 60) Ismene is so afraid of breaking the laws that he left Antigone to go alone.
The next day a guard arrives at the palace to tell Creon of some bad news, “It’s about the corpse. Someone has buried it and disappeared.” (282 - 283) Creon sends the guard to investigate who buried the corpse. Quickly he returns the next day to report of his findings “This here’s the one who carried out the act.We caught her as she was burying the corpse.” (432 -433) The image of this quote brings of importance because no one would ever attempt to break the law made by the king himself but if so how could it be of a women. Creon is quite surprised himself as he realizes what was happening in front of him, anognorisis fill Creons head as he could not belive his own niece would betray him. “You there you with your face bent down towards the ground, what do you say? Do you deny you did this or admit it?” (441 - 443) Creon sentences her to death as he is a man of his word and would not go back on what he has said not to do.
Haimon goes to see Creon about what has happened, Creon assures Haimon that losing Antigone would not affect his life. “Indeed, my son, that’s how your heart should always be resolved, to stand behind your father’s judgment.” (638 – 640) Creon just sees women as objects that can be replaced but Haimon sees it differently. Haimon begins to question Creons actions in defense of Antigone. Haimon leaves angrily threatening his life if Antigone is hurt. Creon did not believe so but a great prophet prophesized many deaths to come. In response Creon went to do the right things but when he arrives at the dungeon Antigone was locked in he finds the Antigone has committed suicide and that his son has done so to. The sudden perpetia overwhelms Creon with emotions as when he returns to the kingdom he finds of the loss of his wife as well leaving him in grief.
Works cited
sophocles."Antigone."Sophocles antigone. Trans. Ian Johnston. 9 Aug 2008. Vancouver island university Malaspina. 26 Nov. 2008 <http://records.viu.ca/~johnstoi/Sophocles/Antigone.htm>
Friday, November 21, 2008
LRJ 1 Letter to antigone
Antigone, if you are found of this crime you have committed, what shall you do? where shall you go? After a night of pondering I have concluded not to tell of your crime in support of your actions. Indeed he is our brother and even if he did betray his own country he will still remain our brother and he should be given a proper burial. Antigone, please forgive your foolish sister for not supporting you until now.
Tuesday, November 11, 2008
Blogging
I rarely blog or go to any sites like Myspace or FaceBook, I like Pc's over Mac's, and know a little html. I like to build Pc's and I like to program, I am very familiar with many Pc operations. I like to play video games because they're entertaining. My favorite subject is Biology and Computer Science, I look forward in becoming a prgramer or a bio-engineer.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
